The Current State of Self-Driving Car Regulations in the U.S.

Explore the complex landscape of U.S. self-driving car regulations. Learn how federal guidelines, state laws, and new bills in 2025 are shaping the future of autonomous vehicles.

Self-driving cars which we also call autonomous vehicles or AVs aren’t just a futuristic dream anymore. Companies are driving them around on public roads, cities are getting ready for them, and lawmakers are hustling to create rules. But there’s one big issue: the U.S. hasn’t got a single national law for autonomous vehicles yet.

Instead, we’re dealing with a messy mix of regulations. On the federal side, agencies like the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) give out voluntary safety guidelines and reporting requirements. At the state level, more than 35 states have come up with their own laws and rules, like testing permits or insurance rules. This makes things really complicated since the rules change based on where you are.

For car makers, tech companies, insurers, and city planners, this confusion is making things tough and expensive. Let’s break down what’s happening right now. 

Federal Guidance: Some Progress But No Solid Law

At the national level, the federal government's been taking baby steps but hasn’t gone all the way to create a solid nationwide law. The NHTSA which is in charge of vehicle safety standards has:

• Provided voluntary safety guidelines for AVs instead of mandatory rules.
• Made it so AV companies have to report crashes through a Standing General Order.
• Expanded exemptions allowing U.S. manufacturers to test prototypes on public roads.
• In 2025, introduced a new framework that changed crash reporting rules and broadened exemption programs.

These actions do show progress but leave some big gaps. For instance, there are no consistent cybersecurity standards, no clear rules on who’s liable, and no binding rules to make sure AV deployment is fair. Because of this, both industries and consumers are left in the dark.

State Rules: A Mixed Bag of Regulations

Since there’s no solid federal law, states have jumped in to fill the void. As of late 2024:

• Over 35 states have passed laws related to AVs.
• None have completely outlawed AVs.
• The rules are all over the place depending on the state.

Here’s how the states differ:

• California: Needs testing permits, safety reports, and black-box type recorders in AVs.
• Nevada & Arizona: Allow fully driverless cars but under strict safety and reporting requirements.
• New York & Florida: Still want a licensed human driver in the car during testing.
• Texas: Calls the vehicle owner the legal “operator” instead of a human driver.
• Colorado & Oklahoma: Ask for emergency protocols and clear notifications for law enforcement.

This creates what experts call a “state-by-state slog.” A company looking to test in different states may end up following totally different rules in each one, which drives up costs and complicates things.

Huge Surge in State Activity

States are not slowing down when it comes to making laws. In just the first few months of 2025, lawmakers in *25 states introduced 67 new bills related to autonomous vehicles.

These bills tackle a wide range of issues, such as:

• Testing rules: Defining where and how AVs can operate.
• Cybersecurity: Setting up protections against hacking or system failures.
• Insurance and liability: Figuring out who’s responsible if an AV gets into a crash.
• Data reporting: Requiring companies to share safety info, crash data, and traffic patterns.
• Law enforcement interactions: Creating protocols for how AVs should respond during pull-overs or emergencies.

The number of new bills shows that states want to steer the direction of AVs. But without federal guidance, each new law adds more complexity to an already tangled web.

Issues with a Fragmented Regulatory System

Having all these different state laws brings its own set of problems:

• Uncertainty for companies – AV manufacturers have to customize their vehicles to meet different state requirements, which slows down nationwide rollout.
• Challenges for city planners – Local governments need to navigate overlapping rules from state and federal levels.
• Safety concerns – Confusing laws might leave gaps or loopholes, raising public safety and accountability issues.
• Consumer trust – People might be hesitant to hop into AVs if the rules seem unclear or vary from state to state.

In short, without a unified federal framework, making self-driving cars common will take longer and cost more than it should.

Hopeful Signs for the Future

Even with these hurdles, there are some positive signs ahead:

• Congress and the new administration have shown interest in developing a national AV strategy that would help standardize rules across the U.S.
• NHTSA’s 2025 framework indicates a push toward consistent safety and crash-reporting standards.
• Research groups and public-private partnerships are working together on big testbeds, AI safety standards, and sensor reliability benchmarks.

These actions hint that while it may take time, the U.S. is slowly heading toward a more harmonized regulatory environment for self-driving cars.

What Cities and Planners Can Do

Until a solid federal law is in place, cities and state agencies have to find their own way through this patchwork. That's where mobility intel platforms Urban SDK come into play.

These tools can help local agencies by:

• Mapping state rules and AV testing zones.
• Analyzing collision data and traffic flows to spot risks.
• Simulating how different rules affect traffic congestion and safety.
• Supporting enforcement by catching unusual driving patterns or near-misses.

With data-driven insights, cities can make smarter planning choices and keep public safety in check while getting ready for the future of autonomous vehicles.

What’s Next on the Horizon?

The rules for autonomous vehicles in the U.S. are going to keep changing rapidly. In the near future, states will keep playing around with their own laws, while federal policies take shape bit by bit.

For now, businesses, lawmakers, and city planners need to remain flexible. By blending regulatory awareness with data-driven tools, they can tackle today’s uncertainties and get ready for a world where self-driving cars are just part of everyday life.

‍